Temporary Threshold Shift (TTS) Studies

Exposure to sound may produce elevated hearing thresholds or threshold shifts in mammals. If the hearing threshold returns to baseline levels then it is known as a temporary threshold shift (TTS). Hearing loss depends on the intensity of the sound, the frequency of the sound, and how long the animal is exposed to the sound (duration). The following tables summarize the available data regarding minimum sound exposures that have been found to cause TTS in a few species of marine mammals. The TTS investigations introduce sounds (pure tones, octave band noise or impulsive sound) at varying frequencies, intensities, and durations to determine sound exposures that cause temporary threshold shifts. The measurements were made on a small number of animals. Individual differences in hearing sensitivities are substantial in land mammals. Without additional data it is impossible to know if the same is true of marine mammals, although it would be surprising if they did not have different hearing sensitivities too.
| Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) |
| Type of Sound |
Duration |
Exposure Frequency (Hz) |
Minimum Intensity at Which TTS Observed (dB re 1 µPa) |
Test Method |
Reference |
| Pure tones |
1 sec |
400 |
None observed up to 193 dB |
Behavioral |
Ref |
3,000
10,000
20,000
75,000 |
194
192
193
182 |
| Octave band noise |
47-54 min |
4,000 -
11,000 |
179 |
Behavioral |
REf |
| Octave band noise |
30 min |
4,000 -
11,000 |
160 |
Auditory Brainstem Response
(ABR) |
REf |
| Impulsive |
|
|
None observed at 221 dB peak-to-peak
(70 kPa peak pressure) |
Behavioral |
REf |
Impulsive
(Seismic watergun) |
|
|
None observed
at 228 dB peak-to-peak
(207 kPa peak pressure) |
Behavioral |
REf |
| Beluga Whale (Delphinapterus leucas) |
| Type of Sound
|
Duration |
Exposure
Frequency
(Hz) |
Minimum
Intensity at
Which TTS
Observed
(dB re 1 µPa) |
Test Method |
Reference |
| Pure tones |
1 sec |
400 |
None observed up to 193 dB |
Behavioral |
|
3,000
10,000
20,000 |
195
192
197 |
| Impulsive |
|
|
None observed at 221 dB peak-to-peak
(70 kPa peak pressure) |
Behavioral |
REf |
Impulsive
(Seismic watergun) |
|
|
226 dB peak-to-peak
(160 kPa peak pressure) |
Behavioral |
REf |
| Harbor Seal (Phoca vitulina) |
| Type of Sound
|
Duration |
Exposure
Frequency
(Hz) |
Minimum
Intensity at
Which TTS
Observed
(dB re 1 µPa) |
Test Method |
Reference |
| Octave-band noise |
20 min |
71-141
353-707
707-1414 |
60 dB above baseline threshold |
Behavioral |
REf |
| California Sea Lion (Zalophus californianus) |
| Type of Sound
|
Duration |
Exposure
Frequency
(Hz) |
Minimum
Intensity at
Which TTS
Observed
(dB re 1 µPa) |
Test Method |
Reference |
| Octave-band noise |
20 min |
707-1414
1414-2828 |
55-65 dB above baseline threshold |
Behavioral |
REf |
| Northern Elephant Seal (Mirounga angustirostris) |
| Type of Sound
|
Duration |
Exposure
Frequency
(Hz) |
Minimum
Intensity at
Which TTS
Observed
(dB re 1 µPa) |
Test Method |
Reference |
| Octave-band noise |
22 min |
707-1414 |
70-75 dB above baseline threshold |
Behavioral |
REf |
Combining the data from all of these studies shows that longer exposures to quieter sounds have the same effect as shorter exposures to louder sounds. The total energy of the sound to which an animal is exposed (a combination of the sound intensity and the duration of exposure to that intensity) is a much better predictor of whether or not TTS will occur than is the sound intensity alone.